Procurement Planning: Shopping Smart for Your Project 🛒
Imagine you’re building a giant treehouse. You need wood, nails, rope, maybe some cool glass windows. But wait—should you make the rope yourself or buy it from a store? Should you hire someone to cut the wood, or do it yourself? That’s exactly what Procurement Planning is all about in project management!
The Big Picture: What is Procurement?
Procurement = Getting stuff (goods/services) from outside your team.
Think of it like this: You’re the captain of a ship, and your ship needs supplies. You can:
- Make things yourself (grow your own food)
- Buy things from others (trade with other ships)
Procurement Planning is deciding what to buy, how to buy it, and from whom.
1. Plan Procurement Management
What Is It?
This is your shopping plan. Before running to the store, smart shoppers make a list!
Plan Procurement Management = Documenting project purchasing decisions, specifying the approach, and identifying potential sellers.
Simple Example
You need 100 chairs for an event:
- Do you buy them or rent them?
- Buy from one store or multiple?
- Pay all at once or in parts?
graph TD A["Project Need"] --> B{Make or Buy?} B -->|Make| C["Use Internal Team"] B -->|Buy| D["Find Sellers"] D --> E["Choose Contract Type"] E --> F["Select Seller"]
Key Outputs
| Output | What It Means |
|---|---|
| Procurement Management Plan | Your shopping rulebook |
| Procurement Strategy | How you’ll approach buying |
| Bid Documents | Forms sellers fill out |
| Source Selection Criteria | How you’ll pick the winner |
2. Make or Buy Analysis
The Core Question
Should we do it ourselves or pay someone else?
This is like deciding: Should I bake a birthday cake or buy one from the bakery?
When to MAKE
✅ You have the skills ✅ You have the time ✅ It’s cheaper to do internally ✅ It’s a secret recipe (proprietary work)
When to BUY
✅ Someone else is an expert ✅ You’re too busy ✅ It’s cheaper outside ✅ You need it only once
Real Example
Building a Mobile App:
| Option | Make | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $150,000 (hire developers) | $80,000 (outsource) |
| Time | 12 months | 6 months |
| Control | Full | Limited |
| Decision | ❌ | ✅ Buy wins! |
The Magic Formula
Total Cost of Making = Direct Costs + Indirect Costs + Opportunity Cost
Total Cost of Buying = Purchase Price + Contract Admin Costs
Choose whichever is LOWER!
3. Procurement Strategy
What Is It?
Your game plan for getting external goods/services. It answers:
- How will we find sellers?
- How will we pick one?
- What contract will we use?
Key Strategy Decisions
graph TD A["Procurement Strategy"] --> B["Delivery Method"] A --> C["Contract Payment Type"] A --> D["Procurement Phases"] B --> E["Single Source?"] B --> F["Multiple Suppliers?"]
Delivery Methods
| Method | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Single Seller | One vendor does everything | One builder makes your whole treehouse |
| Multiple Sellers | Split work among vendors | One makes walls, another makes roof |
| Turnkey | Vendor delivers complete solution | You just get keys to finished treehouse |
Simple Example
Building a Website:
- Strategy 1: Hire one agency for everything (design + development + hosting)
- Strategy 2: Hire designer separately, developer separately, buy hosting separately
- Strategy 3: Use a turnkey platform like Wix
4. Contract Types Overview
The Three Big Families
Think of contracts like paying for a taxi ride:
| Contract Family | How It Works | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed Price | “Drive me to the airport for $50” | Seller takes risk |
| Cost Reimbursable | “I’ll pay whatever the meter says, plus tip” | Buyer takes risk |
| Time & Materials | “I’ll pay $20/hour however long it takes” | Shared risk |
graph LR A["Contract Types"] --> B["Fixed Price"] A --> C["Cost Reimbursable"] A --> D["Time & Materials"] B --> E["Seller Risk ⬆️"] C --> F["Buyer Risk ⬆️"] D --> G["Shared Risk ↔️"]
Quick Rule of Thumb
- Know exactly what you want? → Fixed Price
- Scope is fuzzy? → Cost Reimbursable
- Need flexibility? → Time & Materials
5. Fixed Price Contract Types
The Family of “Set Prices”
Fixed Price contracts are like ordering from a menu—the price is the price!
FFP (Firm Fixed Price)
- Price is locked. No changes.
- Seller eats any cost overruns.
- Example: “Build me a shed for $5,000. Period.”
FPIF (Fixed Price Incentive Fee)
- Base price + bonus for good work.
- Example: “Build for $5,000. Finish early? Get $500 extra!”
FPEPA (Fixed Price with Economic Price Adjustment)
- Price can adjust for inflation or market changes.
- Used for multi-year contracts.
- Example: “Build for $5,000 this year. Next year’s work adjusts with lumber prices.”
Comparison Table
| Type | Price Changes? | Who Bears Risk? | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| FFP | Never | Seller | Clear scope |
| FPIF | Bonus only | Mostly Seller | Motivating seller |
| FPEPA | Economic factors | Shared | Long projects |
6. Cost Reimbursable Contracts
The Family of “Pay What It Costs + Extra”
You pay the seller’s actual costs plus a fee for their profit.
CPFF (Cost Plus Fixed Fee)
- Pay all costs + fixed dollar amount fee.
- Fee doesn’t change regardless of cost.
- Example: “I’ll pay your costs + $10,000 profit, no matter what.”
CPIF (Cost Plus Incentive Fee)
- Pay costs + bonus for performance.
- Good work = bigger fee!
- Example: “Costs + 10% profit. Beat the deadline? 15% profit!”
CPAF (Cost Plus Award Fee)
- Pay costs + subjective bonus.
- Buyer decides how much extra based on satisfaction.
- Example: “Costs + up to $5,000 based on how happy I am.”
CPPC (Cost Plus Percentage of Costs)
- Pay costs + percentage of those costs.
- ⚠️ DANGEROUS! Higher costs = higher profit for seller.
- Often banned in government contracts.
graph TD A["Cost Reimbursable"] --> B["CPFF"] A --> C["CPIF"] A --> D["CPAF"] A --> E["CPPC ⚠️"] B --> F["Fixed Fee"] C --> G["Incentive Fee"] D --> H["Award Fee"] E --> I["% of Costs - Risky!"]
Risk Reality Check
| Type | Seller Motivation | Buyer Risk |
|---|---|---|
| CPFF | Low - fee is fixed | High |
| CPIF | High - bonus awaits | Medium-High |
| CPAF | Medium - subjective | High |
| CPPC | None - wants higher costs! | Very High ⚠️ |
7. Time and Materials (T&M) Contracts
The Flexible Middle Ground
T&M = Pay for time spent + materials used.
Think of hiring a plumber:
- $80/hour for labor
- Plus whatever pipes cost
How It Works
Total Payment = (Hourly Rate × Hours Worked) + Material Costs
Example
Hiring a Consultant:
- Rate: $150/hour
- Hours worked: 40
- Materials: $500 in software licenses
Total = (150 × 40) + 500 = $6,500
When to Use T&M
✅ Scope is unclear ✅ Work is unpredictable ✅ Quick start needed ✅ Small or short projects
When to AVOID T&M
❌ Large, well-defined projects ❌ Seller might pad hours ❌ No budget ceiling
Pro Tip: Add a Ceiling!
T&M with Cap = “Pay hourly, but never more than $20,000 total.”
This protects you from runaway costs!
The Risk Spectrum
Here’s the big picture of who carries risk:
BUYER RISK ←──────────────────────────────→ SELLER RISK
CPPC → CPAF → CPFF → CPIF → T&M → FPEPA → FPIF → FFP
(All risk (Shared) (All risk
on buyer) on seller)
Memory Trick 🧠
- Fixed = Seller Sweats (they’re locked in)
- Cost Plus = Buyer Bleeds (they pay whatever it costs)
- T&M = Both Share (meet in the middle)
Putting It All Together
The Procurement Planning Flow
graph TD A["Identify Need"] --> B["Make or Buy Analysis"] B -->|Buy| C["Develop Procurement Strategy"] C --> D["Choose Contract Type"] D --> E["Prepare Bid Documents"] E --> F["Select Sellers"] F --> G["Award Contract"]
Real-World Scenario
Your company needs a new HR software system:
- Make or Buy? → Buy (software development isn’t your expertise)
- Strategy? → Single seller, competitive bidding
- Contract Type? → Fixed Price (scope is well-defined)
- Specific Type? → FPIF (give bonus for on-time delivery)
Key Takeaways
| Concept | Remember This |
|---|---|
| Plan Procurement Management | Your shopping strategy document |
| Make or Buy | Cost analysis: internal vs. external |
| Procurement Strategy | How you’ll find and select sellers |
| Fixed Price | Locked price, seller takes risk |
| Cost Reimbursable | Pay actual costs + fee, buyer takes risk |
| Time & Materials | Hourly + materials, shared risk |
Final Wisdom
Procurement Planning is about being a smart shopper. You wouldn’t buy a car without:
- Knowing your budget
- Comparing options
- Understanding the warranty
Same with projects! Plan well, choose wisely, and your project will thank you.
Remember: The best contract is one where both parties feel like winners. Fair deals build lasting partnerships!
🎯 You’ve got this!
